Canonical Classics ← 第五十二回
第五十二回
kōngnàojīndōudòng
láiànshìzhǔréngōng

Wukong Makes Havoc at the Cave of the Golden Helmet · The Tathāgata Hints Covertly at the Owner

西天問佛
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

西天問佛 A Resolve to Ask the Buddha

quèshuōtiānwángshuàizhònghuíshànggāofēnghuǒyuànzhāxìngléigōngguàitiānwángfàngdiāowéishuǐzàibàngxíngzhějiànmenmiànxīnyǒuyíngméinàihuáihènqiǎnghuānduìzhòngxiàodào:「lièwèifánnǎodào:『shèngbàibīngjiāzhīcháng。』lùnzhǐdànzhǐshìduōlezhèquānzisuǒwéihàiděngbīngyòutàojiāngleqiěfàngxīndàilǎosūnzàicháchádejiǎolái。」tàidào:「qiánzòuchákān滿mǎntiānshìjiègèngdiǎnzōngjīnquèyòuchùchá?」xíngzhědào:「xiǎngláibiānjīnqiěshàng西tiānwènláijiàozhuóhuìyǎnguānkànzhōukànzhèguàishìfāngshēngzhǎngchùxiāngguànzhùquānzishìjiànshénmebǎobèiguǎnzěndedìngyàolièwèichūhuánděnghuānguītiān。」zhòngshéndào:「yǒujiǔtíngkuàikuài。」quèshuōtiānwángshuàizhònghuíshànggāofēnghuǒyuànzhāxìngléigōngguàitiānwángfàngdiāowéishuǐzàibàngxíngzhějiànmenmiànxīnyǒuyíngméinài怀huáihènqiǎnghuānduìzhòngxiàodào:「lièwèifánnǎodào:『shèngbàibīngjiāzhīcháng。』lùnzhǐdànzhǐshìduōlezhèquānzisuǒwéihàiděngbīngyòutàojiāngleqiěfàngxīndàilǎosūnzàicháchádejiǎolái。」tàidào:「qiánzòuchákānmǎntiānshìjiègèngdiǎnzōngjīnquèyòuchùchá?」xíngzhědào:「xiǎngláibiānjīnqiěshàng西tiānwènláijiàozhuóhuìyǎnguānkànzhōukànzhèguàishìfāngshēngzhǎngchùxiāngguànzhùquānzishìjiànshénmebǎobèiguǎnzěndedìngyàolièwèichūhuánděnghuānguītiān。」zhòngshéndào:「yǒujiǔtíngkuàikuài。」


逐句解 Line by line

quèshuōtiānwángshuàizhònghuíshànggāofēnghuǒyuànzhāxìngléigōngguàitiānwángfàngdiāowéishuǐzàibàng quèshuōtiānwángshuàizhònghuíshànggāofēnghuǒyuànzhāxìngléigōngguàitiānwángfàngdiāowéishuǐzàibàng

Now Devarāja Li led his company back up to the high peak, where the Fire Virtue blamed Nezha for his hot temper, the Thunder Squire blamed the Devarāja for playing tricks, and only the Earl of Waters stood by and said nothing.

Deictic 那李天王: = ; 在傍: = bàng. 放刁 = "to play the sharper, to act awkwardly." 水伯 is the Water Earl, whose flood will be the next thing the ring swallows.

xíngzhějiànmenmiànxīnyǒuyíngméinàihuáihènqiǎnghuānduìzhòngxiàodào:「lièwèifánnǎo xíngzhějiànmenmiànxīnyǒuyíngméinài怀huáihènqiǎnghuānduìzhòngxiàodào:「lièwèifánnǎo

Pilgrim saw that they would not look one another in the face and that their minds were full of misgiving. There was no help for it: nursing his resentment he forced a cheerful manner, and said to them all with a laugh: "My lords, do not distress yourselves.

沒奈何: = méi. 強歡: = qiǎng ("to force, to compel"), not the qiáng of strength — he is forcing the cheerfulness, not being strong about it. 面不廝睹 = "not looking at each other's faces."

dào:『shèngbàibīngjiāzhīcháng。』 dào:『shèngbàibīngjiāzhīcháng。』

"The old saying has it: 'Victory and defeat are the common lot of soldiers.'

One of only two passages in the chapter set in the inner quotation marks 『』. 勝敗兵家之常 is a proverb of long standing, and Pilgrim quotes it to gods who have just lost their weapons for the second time.

lùnzhǐdànzhǐshìduōlezhèquānzisuǒwéihàiděngbīngyòutàojiāngle lùnzhǐdànzhǐshìduōlezhèquānzisuǒwéihàiděngbīngyòutàojiāngle

"He and I are matched in the arts of war, and there is no more to it than that; the only thing is that he has this ring of his over and above, which is why the harm is done, and why he has snared away our weapons again.

The two units are joined at the , which falls inside one sentence. Both = le, positional; 圈子: = zi; 為害: = wéi, the verb ("to work harm"); 套將去了: = jiāng.

qiěfàngxīndàilǎosūnzàicháchádejiǎolái。」 qiěfàngxīndàilǎosūnzàicháchádejiǎolái。」

"Set your minds at rest: let Old Monkey go once more and look into his antecedents."

腳色 — in the vernacular, a person's record and origins, what he is and where he came from; the modern 角色 ("a part in a play") is the same word. Pilgrim is proposing to investigate the demon's identity rather than fight him again, which is the turn the chapter has been waiting for. 查查: both = chá ("to look into"); pypinyin bakes zhā for the reduplication and chá everywhere else, so the reduplicated pair is the silent one.

tàidào:「qiánzòuchákān滿mǎntiānshìjiègèngdiǎnzōngjīnquèyòuchùchá?」 tàidào:「qiánzòuchákānmǎntiānshìjiègèngdiǎnzōngjīnquèyòuchùchá?」

The Prince said: "You laid a memorial before the Jade Emperor earlier, and the whole world under heaven was searched and examined without a single trace of him. Where do you mean to look now?"

太子: = ; 更無: = gèng; 何處: = chù. The objection is a good one, and it is the reason the answer has to come from outside the celestial bureaucracy: the demon is in nobody's register.

xíngzhědào:「xiǎngláibiānjīnqiěshàng西tiānwènláijiàozhuóhuìyǎnguānkànzhōukànzhèguàishìfāngshēngzhǎngchùxiāngguànzhùquānzishìjiànshénmebǎobèi xíngzhědào:「xiǎngláibiānjīnqiěshàng西tiānwènláijiàozhuóhuìyǎnguānkànzhōukànzhèguàishìfāngshēngzhǎngchùxiāngguànzhùquānzishìjiànshénmebǎobèi

Pilgrim said: "It comes to me that the Buddha's dharma is without bounds. Let me go up now to the Western Heaven and ask my Buddha the Tathāgata, and have him turn his eye of wisdom on the four great continents of the earth and see what quarter this monster was born and bred in, what place holds his native home, and what sort of treasure the ring may be.

= throughout (GLOBAL_PY; pypinyin gives in 問我佛). 教他著慧眼: = jiào, causative; = zhuó ("to employ, to apply"). 那方生長 is interrogative and parallel to 何處鄉貫: = ("which quarter"), = zhǎng.

guǎnzěndedìngyàolièwèichūhuánděnghuānguītiān。」 guǎnzěndedìngyàolièwèichūhuánděnghuānguītiān。」

"Come what may I mean to take him, to get satisfaction for you all, and to send you back to Heaven content."

還汝等: = huán ("to send back, to restore"), not hái. 一定 is lexicalized and takes the mechanical before a fourth tone.

zhòngshéndào:「yǒujiǔtíngkuàikuài。」 zhòngshéndào:「yǒujiǔtíngkuàikuài。」

The gods said: "Since that is your intention, do not delay long. Go quickly, go quickly."

The same dismissal — 快去,快去 — that sent him into the cave at the first night's work. The gods' contribution to this chapter has been almost entirely to say it.


總評 Commentary

The recriminations on the ridge are done in one sentence and are worth the whole passage: the Fire Virtue blames Nezha for losing his temper, the Thunder Squire blames Devarāja Li for sharp practice, and the Water Earl — who has not yet been asked to do anything — stands by and says nothing. It is a small, exact picture of a committee after a failure, and the novel does not soften it because these are gods.

Wukong's response is the turn the chapter has been building toward, and it is worth noting how unlike him it is. He quotes a proverb about the fortunes of war, admits that he and the demon are evenly matched in arms, isolates the single variable that is beating them — 他多了這個圈子, he has this ring over and above — and then proposes not another assault but an enquiry into the creature's 腳色, his record and origins. Nezha's objection is the sound one: the Jade Emperor's own search found no trace of him anywhere under heaven. That is precisely why the answer must come from outside the celestial registry, and why Pilgrim is going to Vulture Peak to ask a question rather than to borrow a weapon.