Canonical Classics ← 第五十六回
第五十六回
shénkuángzhūcǎokòu
dàofàngxīnyuán

The Spirit Runs Mad and Puts the Bandits to Death · The Way Is Clouded and the Mind-Monkey Is Cast Off

緊箍咒起
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

緊箍咒起 The Tight-Fillet Spell

shāsēngfàngxiàdànzichānzhetángsēngdào:「shīqǐng。」zhǎnglǎozàixiàzhènglexìngkǒuzhōngniànjǐnerzhòuláixíngzhělēideěrhóngmiànchìyǎnzhàngtóuhūnzàixiàgǔnzhǐjiào:「niànniàn。」zhǎnglǎoniàngòuyǒushíbiànháizhùkǒuxíngzhěfānjīndǒushùqīngtíngténgtòngnánjīnzhǐjiào:「shīráozuìbayǒuhuà便biànshuōniànniàn。」sānzàngquècáizhùkǒudào:「méihuàshuōyàogēnlehuíba。」xíngzhěrěnténgtóudào:「shīzěndejiùgǎn?」sānzàngdào:「zhèhóuxiōngètàishènshìjīngzhīrénzuózàishānxiàliǎngzéitóuguàirénwǎnledàolǎozhězhījiāméngzhāijiè宿yòuméngkāihòuménfàngděngtáolexìngmìngsuīrándeérzixiàogāngāijiùxiāoshǒukuàngyòushāduōrénhuàileduōshǎoshēngmìngshāngletiānduōshǎoquàngèngháoshànniànyàowèikuàizǒukuàizǒumiǎndeyòuniànzhēnyán。」xíngzhěhàizhǐjiào:「niànniàn。」shuōshēngjīndǒuyúnyǐngzōngsuìjiànleshāsēngfàngxiàdànzichānzhetángsēngdào:「shīqǐng。」zhǎnglǎozàixiàzhènglexìngkǒuzhōngniànjǐnerzhòuláixíngzhělēideěrhóngmiànchìyǎnzhàngtóuhūnzàixiàgǔnzhǐjiào:「niànniàn。」zhǎnglǎoniàngòuyǒushíbiànháizhùkǒuxíngzhěfānjīndǒushùqīngtíngténgtòngnánjīnzhǐjiào:「shīráozuìbayǒuhuà便biànshuōniànniàn。」sānzàngquècáizhùkǒudào:「méihuàshuōyàogēnlehuíba。」xíngzhěrěnténgtóudào:「shīzěndejiùgǎn?」sānzàngdào:「zhèhóuxiōngètàishènshìjīngzhīrénzuózàishānxiàliǎngzéitóuguàirénwǎnledàolǎozhězhījiāméngzhāijiè宿yòuméngkāihòuménfàngděngtáolexìngmìngsuīrándeérzixiàogāngāijiùxiāoshǒukuàngyòushāduōrénhuàileduōshǎoshēngmìngshāngletiānduōshǎoquàngèngháoshànniànyàowèikuàizǒukuàizǒumiǎndeyòuniànzhēnyán。」xíngzhěhàizhǐjiào:「niànniàn。」shuōshēngjīndǒuyúnyǐngzōngsuìjiànle


逐句解 Line by line

shāsēngfàngxiàdànzichānzhetángsēngdào:「shīqǐng。」 shāsēngfàngxiàdànzichānzhetángsēngdào:「shīqǐng。」

Sha Monk set down the load, helped the Tang Monk up by the arm and said, “Master, please rise.”

攙著 is the durative . 擔子 is suffixed, so is zi. Sha Monk’s function in this chapter has been to pick people up and to tell them to stop arguing.

zhǎnglǎozàixiàzhènglexìngkǒuzhōngniànjǐnerzhòuláixíngzhělēideěrhóngmiànchìyǎnzhàngtóuhūnzàixiàgǔnzhǐjiào:「niànniàn。」 zhǎnglǎozàixiàzhènglexìngkǒuzhōngniànjǐnerzhòuláixíngzhělēideěrhóngmiànchìyǎnzhàngtóuhūnzàixiàgǔnzhǐjiào:「niànniàn。」

The elder, on the ground, composed himself, and began to recite the Tight-Fillet spell, which squeezed Pilgrim till his ears were red and his face burned, till his eyes bulged and his head swam and he rolled about on the ground crying only, “Stop, stop!”

takes the colloquial lēi, to draw tight — the fillet physically constricts the skull. This is a ruling of the Ch.56 close: was held invariant at corpus-wide, which is right for 勒馬, to rein in, and wrong here; the graph now sits in the direct-verify polyphone list and takes a reading per occurrence. 緊箍兒 is suffixed, so is er. 只教 is as jiào.

zhǎnglǎoniàngòuyǒushíbiànháizhùkǒu zhǎnglǎoniàngòuyǒushíbiànháizhùkǒu

The elder recited it a good ten times and more, and still would not stop.

is hái — still, even then. 不住口 is not to close the mouth.

xíngzhěfānjīndǒushùqīngtíngténgtòngnánjīnzhǐjiào:「shīráozuìbayǒuhuà便biànshuōniànniàn。」 xíngzhěfānjīndǒushùqīngtíngténgtòngnánjīnzhǐjiào:「shīráozuìbayǒuhuà便biànshuōniànniàn。」

Pilgrim turned somersaults and stood on his head, unable to bear the pain, and called out only, “Master, forgive my fault! If you have something to say, say it — only stop, stop.”

keeps its standing invariant jīn and is dǒu, the somersault, against pypinyin’s dòu. 難禁 gives as nán and as jīn, to bear — the endurance reading, not the jìn of prohibition. is sentence-final, so the particle ba.

sānzàngquècáizhùkǒudào:「méihuàshuōyàogēnlehuíba。」 sānzàngquècáizhùkǒudào:「méihuàshuōyàogēnlehuíba。」

Only then did Tripitaka stop. “I have nothing to say. I do not want you following me any longer. Go back.”

沒話說 is as méi. Both in this passage are sentence-final particles, against the verb of 茶罷 and 便罷. 我不要你跟了 is eight graphs, and it ends fifty-six chapters of discipleship.

xíngzhěrěnténgtóudào:「shīzěndejiùgǎn?」 xíngzhěrěnténgtóudào:「shīzěndejiùgǎn?」

Pilgrim bore the pain and knocked his head on the ground: “Master, why do you drive me away like this?”

怎的 puts in its interrogative-suffix use. 磕頭 is the full prostration, and Wukong performs it while the fillet is still tight on his skull.

sānzàngdào:「zhèhóuxiōngètàishènshìjīngzhīrén sānzàngdào:「zhèhóuxiōngètàishènshìjīngzhīrén

Tripitaka said, “You wretched monkey, your ferocity is far too great. You are no man to be fetching scriptures.”

兇惡 is as è, wicked — the ordinary reading, against the of 甚惡你等 in the farmstead. 太甚 is as the intensifier shèn. The indictment that follows is structured like a formal charge, and this is the first count.

zuózàishānxiàliǎngzéitóuguàirén zuózàishānxiàliǎngzéitóuguàirén

“Yesterday, below the mountain slope, you beat those two robber chiefs to death, and I already blamed you then for want of humanity.”

不仁 — want of ren — is the Confucian charge, not the Buddhist one, and it is the word Tripitaka reaches for first.

wǎnledàolǎozhězhījiāméngzhāijiè宿yòuméngkāihòuménfàngděngtáolexìngmìng wǎnledàolǎozhězhījiāméngzhāijiè宿yòuméngkāihòuménfàngděngtáolexìngmìng

“Then, when evening came and we reached the old man’s house, we had his kindness for our meal and our lodging, and his kindness again when he opened the back gate and let us escape with our lives.”

twice — to receive as a favour — is the register of obligation. 借宿 is 宿 as . The second count is not cruelty but ingratitude.

suīrándeérzixiàogāngāijiùxiāoshǒu suīrándeérzixiàogāngāijiùxiāoshǒu

“Unworthy as his son was, and no concern of mine, still you should not have struck off his head;”

無干 keeps at its standing invariant gān. 梟首 is the legal term for decapitation and public exposure of the head — Tripitaka is charging his disciple in the vocabulary of a magistrate. The ;-split members here are successive steps of an argument, so J1 declines to join them.

kuàngyòushāduōrénhuàileduōshǎoshēngmìngshāngletiānduōshǎo kuàngyòushāduōrénhuàileduōshǎoshēngmìngshāngletiānduōshǎo

“And beyond that you have killed many more, destroyed I know not how many lives, and injured I know not how much of the harmony of Heaven and Earth.”

況又 marks the escalation. 和氣 — the harmony of Heaven and Earth — moves the charge from law to cosmology, which is the third and gravest count.

quàngèngháoshànniànyàowèi quàngèngháoshànniànyàowèi

“Time and again I have counselled you, and there is not a hair’s weight of good thought in you. What do I want you for?”

更無 is as gèng, still less. 一毫 takes mechanical sandhi to before the second-tone . 要你何為 is the purposive wèi, on the pattern of 摸他何為.

kuàizǒukuàizǒumiǎndeyòuniànzhēnyán。」 kuàizǒukuàizǒumiǎndeyòuniànzhēnyán。」

“Go, go — before I recite the True Words again.”

免得 keeps neutral. 真言 is mantra, the Sanskrit term, used here for the fillet spell. Ten graphs, and the threat is the same instrument that has just been used.

xíngzhěhàizhǐjiào:「niànniàn。」 xíngzhěhàizhǐjiào:「niànniàn。」

Pilgrim was afraid, and cried only, “Stop, stop — I am going.”

只教 is again as jiào. Wukong’s last words in the chapter are the same two he has been saying since the spell began.

shuōshēngjīndǒuyúnyǐngzōngsuìjiànle shuōshēngjīndǒuyúnyǐngzōngsuìjiànle

He said the word and went — one road of somersault cloud, without shadow or trace — and so was gone.

一路 takes mechanical sandhi to before the fourth-tone ; keeps its standing invariant jīn. 遂不見了 is sixteen graphs of departure and no farewell.


總評 Commentary

Tripitaka’s indictment is carefully built, and it is the most coherent thing he says in the whole chapter. Three counts, in ascending order: 不仁, want of humanity, for the two robbers on the mountain; ingratitude, for repaying the household that fed and saved them by killing its only son; and 傷了天地多少和氣, injury to the harmony of Heaven and Earth, for the rest. Confucian, then social, then cosmological. He has been thinking about this since the grave.

But the instrument is the fillet, and the fillet undermines the argument. The spell was given to Guanyin as a means of control precisely because reason would not serve, and Tripitaka recites it ten times over while his disciple rolls on the ground, then delivers the moral charge to a man in too much pain to answer, then threatens the spell again to make him leave. The judgement may be right; the procedure is torture.

Wukong never disputes any of it. He asks one question — 怎的就趕我去耶, why drive me away — and then goes. He does not defend the killings, or plead his service, or repeat the counterfactual he used at the grave. The disciple who answered every moral demand in this chapter with a joke or a threat has nothing at all to say to the one that ends the arrangement.

說聲去一路觔斗雲無影無蹤遂不見了. The novel gives his departure sixteen graphs and no adjective. He said the word and went. The mind-monkey has been set loose, which is what the chapter title promised in its second half, and the promise has taken six thousand graphs to keep.