Canonical Classics ← 第五十三回
第五十三回
chánzhǔtūncānhuáiguǐyùn
huángyùnshuǐjiěxiétāi

The Master of Dhyāna, Swallowing His Meal, Conceives a Ghostly Pregnancy · The Yellow Dame Draws Water and Dissolves the Demon Foetus

無藥可醫
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

無藥可醫 No Medicine to Be Had

sānzànghēngzhedào:「poazhèyǒujiājiàomǎitiēduòtāiyàochīlexiàtāiláiba。」zidào:「jiùyǒuyàoshìzhǐshìmenzhèzhèngnánjiēshàngyǒuzuòjiěyángshānshānzhōngyǒuérdòngdòngyǒuyǎnluòtāiquánquánshuǐchīkǒufāngcáijiěletāiquèjīndeshuǐlexiàngniánláiledàorénchēngmíngzhēnxiānérdònggǎizuòxiānānzhùluòtāiquánshuǐkěnshànréndànqiúshuǐzhěyàohuāhóngbiǎoyángjiǔguǒpánzhìchéngfèngxiànzhǐbàiqiúwǎnershuǐlimenzhèxíngjiǎosēngzěnmeduōqiáncáimǎibàndànzhǐāimìngdàishíérshēngchǎnle。」xíngzhěwényán滿mǎnxīnhuāndào:「pozhèdàojiěyángshānyǒuduōchéng?」podào:「yǒusānshí。」xíngzhědào:「hǎolehǎoleshīfàngxīndàilǎosūnxiēshuǐláichī。」sānzànghēngzhedào:「poazhèyǒujiājiàomǎitiēduòtāiyàochīlexiàtāiláiba。」zidào:「jiùyǒuyàoshìzhǐshìmenzhèzhèngnánjiēshàngyǒuzuòjiěyángshānshānzhōngyǒuérdòngdòngyǒuyǎnluòtāiquánquánshuǐchīkǒufāngcáijiěletāiquèjīndeshuǐlexiàngniánláiledàorénchēngmíngzhēnxiānérdònggǎizuòxiānānzhùluòtāiquánshuǐkěnshànréndànqiúshuǐzhěyàohuāhóngbiǎoyángjiǔguǒpánzhìchéngfèngxiànzhǐbàiqiúwǎnershuǐlimenzhèxíngjiǎosēngzěnmeduōqiáncáimǎibàndànzhǐāimìngdàishíérshēngchǎnle。」xíngzhěwényánmǎnxīnhuāndào:「pozhèdàojiěyángshānyǒuduōchéng?」podào:「yǒusānshí。」xíngzhědào:「hǎolehǎoleshīfàngxīndàilǎosūnxiēshuǐláichī。」


逐句解 Line by line

sānzànghēngzhedào:「poazhèyǒujiā sānzànghēngzhedào:「poazhèyǒujiā

Tripitaka groaned, "Grandmother, is there a physician hereabouts?

哼著 is durative zhe. He asks for a doctor before asking what is wrong with him, which is characteristic — the remedy is sought before the diagnosis is accepted.

jiàomǎitiēduòtāiyàochīlexiàtāiláiba。」 jiàomǎitiēduòtāiyàochīlexiàtāiláiba。」

Let my disciple go and buy a dose of abortive medicine to take, and bring the thing down and be done."

is causative jiào. is the sentence-final hortative ba, not the verb . The request is put with a briskness the novel does not comment on: the holiest man in the party proposes an abortion in eighteen graphs.

zidào:「jiùyǒuyàoshì zidào:「jiùyǒuyàoshì

The old woman said, "Medicine would be no use even if we had any.

就有 is the concessive frame — even granting the premise, the conclusion fails. She dismisses the whole medical approach in eleven graphs.

zhǐshìmenzhèzhèngnánjiēshàngyǒuzuòjiěyángshānshānzhōngyǒuérdòngdòngyǒuyǎnluòtāiquán zhǐshìmenzhèzhèngnánjiēshàngyǒuzuòjiěyángshānshānzhōngyǒuérdòngdòngyǒuyǎnluòtāiquán

It is only that away to the south of us there is a Mount Dissolving-Yang, and in that mountain a Child-Destroying Cave, and in the cave a spring of Fetus-Dissolving Water.

解陽 is jiě, to loosen or dissolve — the mountain undoes the yang principle the posthouse was named for welcoming. 破兒洞 takes as ér, the child-morpheme. The three names nest inside one another, mountain to cave to spring, and the sentence's syntax reproduces the nesting.

quánshuǐchīkǒufāngcáijiěletāi quánshuǐchīkǒufāngcáijiěletāi

One must get a mouthful of that spring's water to drink, and only then is the fetal humour dissolved.

須得 takes as , to obtain, governing the noun phrase that follows. 胎氣 is the pneuma of conception rather than a fetus as such, which is why it can be dissolved rather than expelled.

quèjīndeshuǐle quèjīndeshuǐle

But nowadays the water is not to be got.

取不得 is a potential complement, so is de. Eight graphs, and the whole shape of the rest of the chapter is in them.

xiàngniánláiledàorénchēngmíngzhēnxiānérdònggǎizuòxiānānzhùluòtāiquánshuǐkěnshànrén xiàngniánláiledàorénchēngmíngzhēnxiānérdònggǎizuòxiānānzhùluòtāiquánshuǐkěnshànrén

Some years back there came a Daoist, styling himself the True Immortal As-You-Will, who turned that Child-Destroying Cave into a Convent of Assembled Immortals, took the Fetus-Dissolving Spring under his protection, and will not bestow the water freely.

如意 — as one wishes — is the name of a wish-granting sceptre, and as a title it is pointed: he has made a spring that answers other people's needs answer only his own. is chēng, to style oneself. 善賜 is to give without exacting return.

dànqiúshuǐzhěyàohuāhóngbiǎoyángjiǔguǒpánzhìchéngfèngxiànzhǐbàiqiúwǎnershuǐli dànqiúshuǐzhěyàohuāhóngbiǎoyángjiǔguǒpánzhìchéngfèngxiànzhǐbàiqiúwǎnershuǐli

Any who would seek the water must have silk and red cloth for a presentation gift, mutton and wine and platters of fruit, offered with perfect sincerity — and only by prostrating and begging do they get one bowl of water from him.

求得 takes as , obtained by seeking. 碗兒 takes the diminutive suffix er; is li by a corpus-wide ruling. The list of required offerings is the vocabulary of formal ritual presentation, which is exactly what makes it extortion.

menzhèxíngjiǎosēngzěnmeduōqiáncáimǎibàn menzhèxíngjiǎosēngzěnmeduōqiáncáimǎibàn

You mendicant monks — how are you to come by so much money to purchase it?

行腳僧 is a monk who travels on foot and owns nothing, which is the point of her question. is again , to come by.

dànzhǐāimìngdàishíérshēngchǎnle。」 dànzhǐāimìngdàishíérshēngchǎnle。」

You can only bear it out, and wait for the time, and give birth, and there's an end."

挨命 is āi, to endure through. 罷了 closes with the verb , to have done — and that is that. Her counsel is resignation, which is the one thing this party has never accepted.

xíngzhěwényán滿mǎnxīnhuāndào:「pozhèdàojiěyángshānyǒuduōchéng?」 xíngzhěwényánmǎnxīnhuāndào:「pozhèdàojiěyángshānyǒuduōchéng?」

Pilgrim, hearing this, was filled with delight and said, "Grandmother, how far is it from here to that Mount Dissolving-Yang?"

滿心歡喜 is the passage's hinge. Everyone else has heard an impossibility; Wukong has heard an address. 聞得 takes as by the standing ruling.

podào:「yǒusānshí。」 podào:「yǒusānshí。」

The old woman said, "It is thirty li."

is left untransliterated as a unit of measure, per the standing policy on , , and the rest. Thirty li is a trivial distance to a cloud-somersault.

xíngzhědào:「hǎolehǎole xíngzhědào:「hǎolehǎole

Pilgrim said, "Good, good.

Both are the aspectual le and take positional fixspecs. The doubled 好了 answers the old woman's 好耍子 from two passages earlier — her amusement met by his.

shīfàngxīndàilǎosūnxiēshuǐláichī。」 shīfàngxīndàilǎosūnxiēshuǐláichī。」

Set your mind at rest, Master; wait while Old Monkey fetches you some water."

待老孫 uses the third-person self-reference that is Wukong's habitual register when he is about to do something impressive.


總評 Commentary

The old woman's second speech converts the chapter from a predicament into a quest, and it does so by supplying three things in order: a cure, an obstacle, and a distance. The cure is a spring; the obstacle is a Daoist who has enclosed it; the distance is thirty li. Only the third of these is of any interest to Wukong, and the narrative gives his reaction — 滿心歡喜 — in the same breath as the information.

The naming continues the pattern established at the Child-and-Mother River. 解陽山 dissolves the yang that 迎陽館 welcomed; 破兒洞 destroys the child that 照胎泉 confirmed. The country's toponymy is a closed system in which conception and its undoing are both institutional facilities, sited a day's walk apart, and the novel lays it out with the flatness of a gazetteer.

What has changed is the introduction of an antagonist, and the form he takes is worth noting. 如意真仙 has committed no violence and abducted nobody. He has enclosed a spring and instituted a tariff — silk, mutton, wine, fruit, and prostration — for water that was formerly free. The offerings he demands are the standard furniture of respectful petition, which is precisely what makes the arrangement extortion rather than piety: he has taken the outward forms of reverence and attached them to a monopoly.

The old woman's closing advice is the only genuinely bleak note in the chapter. Her counsel to the poor is to endure, wait, and give birth, because the toll is beyond them — 你們這行腳僧怎麼得許多錢財買辦? The remedy exists, is thirty li away, and is priced out of reach. That the pilgrims will simply take it by force does not invalidate her point; it distinguishes them from her neighbours, who cannot.