Canonical Classics ← 第六十回
第六十回
niúwángzhànhuáyán
sūnxíngzhěèr調tiáojiāoshàn

The Bull Demon King Breaks Off the Fight for a Splendid Banquet · Sun the Pilgrim Contrives the Second Fetching of the Banana-Leaf Fan

放火之輩
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

放火之輩 The Sage Accused of Arson

shuō:「wángniúwáng。」xíngzhědào:「zhèshānběnshìniúwángfàngdehuǒjiǎmínghuǒyànshān?」dào:「shìshìshèngruòkěnshèxiǎoshénzhīzuìfānggǎnzhíyán。」xíngzhědào:「yǒuzuìzhíshuōfáng。」dào:「zhèhuǒyuánshìshèngfàngde。」xíngzhědào:「zàizhèděngluàntánshìfànghuǒzhībèi?」shuō:「wángniúwáng。」xíngzhědào:「zhèshānběnshìniúwángfàngdehuǒjiǎmínghuǒyànshān?」dào:「shìshìshèngruòkěnshèxiǎoshénzhīzuìfānggǎnzhíyán。」xíngzhědào:「yǒuzuìzhíshuōfáng。」dào:「zhèhuǒyuánshìshèngfàngde。」xíngzhědào:「zàizhèděngluàntánshìfànghuǒzhībèi?」


逐句解 Line by line

shuō:「wángniúwáng。」 shuō:「wángniúwáng。」

The Local Spirit said, "The King of Great Strength is none other than the Bull Demon King."

The chapter opens in mid-dialogue, on the Local Spirit's answer to the question the previous chapter closed upon; there is no 話說 or 卻說 at the head. is the copula of flat identification: not a comparison but an equation.

xíngzhědào:「zhèshānběnshìniúwángfàngdehuǒjiǎmínghuǒyànshān?」 xíngzhědào:「zhèshānběnshìniúwángfàngdehuǒjiǎmínghuǒyànshān?」

Pilgrim said, "Then the fire on this mountain was set by the Bull Demon King, and the name Mountain of Flames is a false one?"

假名 here is jiǎ, false or assumed, not jià a leave of absence. Pilgrim's guess is that the name conceals an agent — which is right in form and wrong in person.

dào:「shìshìshèngruòkěnshèxiǎoshénzhīzuìfānggǎnzhíyán。」 dào:「shìshìshèngruòkěnshèxiǎoshénzhīzuìfānggǎnzhíyán。」

"No, no," said the Local Spirit. "If the Great Sage will pardon this humble deity's offence, only then would I dare speak plainly."

小神 is the self-abasing form a minor deity uses before a superior. The Local Spirit asks pardon before naming the offence, which is itself the tell: the offence is one the Great Sage will not want to hear.

xíngzhědào:「yǒuzuìzhíshuōfáng。」 xíngzhědào:「yǒuzuìzhíshuōfáng。」

Pilgrim said, "What offence have you? Speak out; there is no harm in it."

Two clauses the source separates with a question mark are rejoined here as one speaker turn.

dào:「zhèhuǒyuánshìshèngfàngde。」 dào:「zhèhuǒyuánshìshèngfàngde。」

The Local Spirit said, "This fire was, at its origin, set by the Great Sage himself."

carries the weight of the sentence: not that the Sage tends the fire now, but that he is its origin.

xíngzhědào:「zàizhèděngluàntánshìfànghuǒzhībèi?」 xíngzhědào:「zàizhèděngluàntánshìfànghuǒzhībèi?」

Pilgrim said in anger, "Where was I? You talk such nonsense. Am I the sort of creature who sets fires?"

is here, the rhetorical interrogative, not the deictic — Pilgrim is not pointing at a place but denying he was ever at one. pypinyin bakes at this site. 之輩 is dismissive: not a person but a class of person.


總評 Commentary

The chapter begins with no formula at all. Where a reader expects 話說 or 卻說 to reopen the narration, the text simply resumes the Local Spirit in mid-sentence, answering the question that closed the previous chapter. The effect is that of a curtain that never fell: the interrogation on the Mountain of Flames has been running continuously, and the reader is returned to it without ceremony.

The exchange is built as a slow reversal. Pilgrim proposes a culprit — the Bull Demon King, whose name he has just been given — and the Local Spirit refuses it twice before asking, in the language of a minor official petitioning a great one, for pardon in advance. Only then does he name the arsonist, and the arsonist is the interrogator. The comedy is exact: the Great Sage has spent the whole of the previous chapter demanding to know who is responsible for an obstacle, and the answer is that he is.

Pilgrim's indignation is the joke's second half. 我可是放火之輩 — am I the sort who sets fires — is a rhetorical question with an unambiguous answer, and the novel has spent seven chapters establishing it. The reader supplies what Pilgrim will not. This is the structural principle the whole Mountain of Flames episode turns upon: the obstacle in the pilgrims' path is not an accident of geography but a debt, and the debtor is the one being obstructed.